• Home
  • Advanced Search
  • Market Reports
  • About
  • Contact Us
Login
813-293-9996

Sign in to your account

Need to reset your phone number?

Don't have an account with us?

Click here to sign up.

Bay Island Homes for Sale

Address Search

Bay Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bay Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Siesta Key, Florida. This picturesque subdivision offers an idyllic coastal lifestyle, where sun-soaked days and tranquil sunsets are a daily delight. With its prime location in Sarasota County, Bay Island is perfectly positioned to provide residents with both the serenity of island living and the vibrancy of nearby urban amenities.

Homes for sale in Bay Island are a true reflection of the area’s charm, featuring a variety of architectural styles that cater to diverse tastes. From cozy beach cottages to elegant waterfront estates, each property is designed to maximize comfort and style while taking full advantage of the stunning natural surroundings. Many homes boast expansive outdoor spaces, perfect for entertaining or simply soaking in the beauty of the Florida sun. With easy access to private beaches and scenic waterways, residents can enjoy a lifestyle filled with boating, fishing, and beachcombing.

Bay Island is not just about beautiful homes; it offers a close-knit community atmosphere where neighbors become friends. The lush landscaping and well-maintained common areas create an inviting environment for families and retirees alike. Nearby, you’ll find a range of dining, shopping, and recreational options that make everyday living a pleasure.

If you’re searching for your dream home in a serene, picturesque setting, Bay Island in Siesta Key is the perfect place to call home. Explore our listings today and discover the unmatched beauty and charm this delightful community has to offer!

Newest Bay Island Homes for Sale

838 Norsota Way, Sarasota image
838 Norsota Way, Sarasota $4,190,000

Pre-Construction. To be built. To be complete in a few months. Discover timeless coastal elegance in this upcoming traditional-style new construction home, perfectly situ...

  • 5 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
604 Norsota Way, Sarasota image
604 Norsota Way, Sarasota $3,950,000

Welcome to an exceptional newly renovated residence in the highly coveted Bay Island neighborhood on north Siesta Key, where timeless coastal architecture and modern luxu...

  • 5 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
546 Freeling Drive, Sarasota image
546 Freeling Drive, Sarasota $12,500,000

Pre-Construction. To be built. Discover an extraordinary opportunity to own an expansive double lot of 0.52 acres on North Siesta Key with this single-story, new construc...

  • 5 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
3799 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota image
3799 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota $17,650,000

Four Seasons Hotel in Bali or private estate? Set on more than an acre of coveted waterfront property along the prestigious north end of Siesta Key, this extraordinary Ba...

  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
3820 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota image
3820 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota $8,750,000 ▲

Under Construction. Move in before the 2026 holidays. Absolute best value for new construction on N Siesta Key in prime Bay Island location with easy access to downtown S...

  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
Like or Share

Address Search

View Bay Island Home Values

  • Bay Island Home Values

Browse Bay Island Homes by Property Type

  • Homes for Sale
  • Land for Sale

Browse Bay Island Homes by Water Frontage

  • Bay Front
  • Bay View
  • Beach Access
  • Beach Front
  • Beach View
  • Boatable Water
  • Lake Front
  • Sailboat Water

Browse Bay Island Homes by Community Extras

  • No Deed Restriction

Browse Bay Island Homes by Garage Description

  • 3 Car Garage
  • 5+ Car Garage

Browse Bay Island Homes by Architectural style

  • Coastal
  • Custom

Browse Bay Island Homes by View

  • City
  • Gulf/Ocean to Bay
  • Water

Browse Bay Island Homes by Exterior Features

  • Awning(s)
  • Balcony
  • Fire Pit
  • Lighting
  • Outdoor Grill
  • Outdoor Kitchen
  • Outdoor Shower
  • Private Entrance
  • Private Mailbox
  • Private Yard
  • Rain Gutters
  • Storage

Browse Bay Island Homes by Pool type

  • No Pool
  • Private

Browse Bay Island Homes by Property Description

  • One Story
  • Two Story

Browse Bay Island Homes by Exterior Construction

  • Block
  • Stucco

Browse Bay Island Homes by Frontage

  • Bay/Harbor
  • Canal - Saltwater
  • Lagoon
  • Home
  • Advanced Search
  • Selling
  • Buying
  • About Us
  • Featured Properties
  • Contact Us

Premier Sotheby's International Realty
120 2nd Ave NE, Suite 102-A
St Petersburg, FL 33701
Office: 727-898-6800 Cell: 813-293-9996

             

© All Rights Reserved

  • Tampa
  • St Petersburg
  • Clearwater
  • Tampa / Carrollwood
  • Treasure Island
  • Pass a Grille Bch/St Pete Bch/Treasure Isl
  • Riverview
  • Brandon
  • Lakewood Ranch
  • Dunedin
  • Clearwater Beach
  • Clearwater/Belleair
  • Wesley Chapel
  • Apollo Beach
  • Historic Old Northeast
  • Hyde Park
  • Altura Bayshore
  • The Nolen
  • One St Petersburg Condo
  • 400 Central
  • Marina Pointe
  • Culbreath Bayou
  • Tampa / Palma Ceia
  • Belleair Bch/Shores/Indian Rocks Bch
  • Hillsborough County
  • Pinellas County
  • Sarasota County
  • Boca Grande
  • Bradenton Beach
  • Palm Harbor
IDX Real Estate Websites by
• Accessibility • Terms • Privacy